Live tweets from Day 4 of the Sara Morrison v Belfast Film Festival employment tribunal.
Session 1:
66 tweets
Good morning and welcome to Killymeal House Belfast for Day 4 Session 1 of Morrison v Belfast Film Festival. Proceedings are due to begin at 11am. It is raining again.

Here are some bedraggled camera-folk, to cheer you up.

This is last night's BBC NI report on yesterday's proceedings.
Okay we are underway – for various scheduling reasons there is going to be a pause in Belfast Film Festival CEO Michele Devlin’s (MD) evidence and BFF director Mark Cousins (MC) is going to start giving his evidence.
J = Employment Judge Lisa Sturgeon
P = her and her panel Professor Deborah Boyd and Michael McKeown
SD = Sean Doherty, BFF barrister
NC = Naomi Cunningham, Sara Morrison’s barrister
SM – Sara Morrison – Claimant (C)
BFF = Respondent – R
MC is sworn in
NC I want to start at par 2 of your Witness Statement (WS) – “The Respondent organisation has been clearly supportive of the LGBT community in greater Belfast for many years. It would be impossible to work there and not know…
that. The background here is the historic state, church, institutional and (often) family
shaming, silencing (or worse) of LGBT people in Ireland and elsewhere This has
been shifting in recent years. I often say that Ireland jumped from the 19th Century to
the 21st Century on the subject; cultural organisation, brave individuals and principled
politicians have helped bring about this shift, which has of course improved the lives
of thousands of our fellow citizens.”
NC can I take from this you think the situation has improved
MC I come from round here and gender-critical (GC) are in the majority – they’re not a minority group
NC No most people know that you can’t change sex
MC says that he has studied science and whilst he doesn’t quite say sex is a spectrum he starts talking about flowers and trees
NC but all human beings come from a female
MC accepts that all human beings have come from a mother
NC it’s right that shaming a marginalised group is a bad thing
MC yes
NC and you have taken a side in this
MC I passionately care for the rights of trans people, and, I hope everyone
NC and you have done so since 2013
MC and I think you’ll see I have never used derogatory language against people – certain acronyms
NC TERF?
MC yes – I would not use that and I would be very surprised if you could find me doing so
NC I’m not laying a trap for you – I don’t have anything here which suggests you have
MC I always think you play the ball and not the person – so I don’t call people racist but I say they have been
(sorry) said something racist with the exception of Donald Trump I never use derogatory terms about anyone
J this is all a very interesting social conversation but we have to stick to the list of issues
NC I would like to explore the word TERF with Mr Cousins – you know it is a term of abuse
MC It can be used as a term of abuse, but if you look at what it stands for there is nothing abusive in it
NC is suggesting that if MC stated a GC view it would be career-ending MC pushes back and says it is possible to apologise and move on
NC picks up the Bolshie Bish tweet: "Who's driving 4.5 hours up to Belfast Sunday just
to tell a transphobe to go fxck herself, and then
driving 4.5 hours home??"
NC can we see from the combination of the trans flag, the name, and the aggressive sentiment – that this is a trans woman?
SD why does it matter
NC it will be become clear in the next question
MC I can't answer that – I have no idea who this person is
NC okay if I'm right – this is a man who is travelling a large distance to abuse a woman
SD we have no evidence this person is a man
NC whether this person is male or female that that as a response to women asserting their rights is wholly unacceptable
MC I don't like it at all
NC you say in par 3 that "I was surprised to hear that the Claimant, who was Inclusion/Audience Development
Co-Ordinator with the Respondent, had criticised many of the organisations that the
Respondent had worked with"
NC which ones had they worked with
MC I can't remember
NC you confirmed your statement is true – what work had the R done with the groups mentioned?
MC I don't know. I'm a board member.
NC you're saying in your sworn statement that these were organisations you had worked with
MC when I made this statement I checked
… that we had worked with these orgs – but it doesn't matter – but when I saw the video I thought it was really was inappropriate to denounce our treasured partner orgs who are acclaimed for the work they do
NC let's go to the transcript of Sara's speech at LWS?
MC sure
NC which of these organisations are your "treasured partner organisations"
MC I know we have had relationships with most of them. One of the things I like about the BFF is the way we partner with community groups.
NC you haven't partnered with the WRN network yet have you
MC no
NC do you think you should?
MC yes – I think we should partner with any orgs prepared to have discussions in a non aggressive way
NC you weren't present at 4 May board meeting, but you were brought up to speed on 25th. You said: "Hi Michele. Have tried to find the video of the Trans rally
that Sarah [sic] spoke at. Was it the Let Women Speak event, at which Parker Posey [sic] spoke and Graham Lenehan [sic] attended? If so this is more serious than I thought. I would like to email the chairs."
NC why is it serious that SM shared a platform with Posie Parker (PP)
MC because we don't want to be associated with extremist views, and it's not just here – there was someone else Jolene Bunting who was there wearing a at t-shirt with a gun to someone's head and a rainbow flag
MC saying know your enemy – that's awful
NC so if someone says something at an event that's beyond the pale that taints everyone
MC I don't believe in guilt by association
NC could you explain to the panel what LWS is – you understand the premise, presumably
MC Just before LWS was in Belfast they were supported by Nazi's sieg heiling and I'm not saying they wanted them there, but they attract extremes and they bring tension
MC we never said that Sara was guilty of anything it's about "getting dirty by association" with extremists
NC you are saying that if SM shared a platform with Posie Parker "it's even more serious than I thought"
MC yes we as a org need to express love to the community as an antidote to the LWS and extremist views being platformed
[we move on to MC's email to MD re his convo with SM on 25 June in a pub] He says:
"I found the whole thing troubling for several reasons. (1) There seemed to be the suggestion that Michele of spreading false information; I told Sara that I had heard reports of her speech from several sources including other board members. (2) There was no hint of regret for, or doubt about, what she did. As you'll know "I'm standing up for the rights of women" is the argument used by conservatives and religious people in several countries, and a new staple of the anti-LGBTQanti-lslamic right.
[we also go to a picture of MD in a t-shirt saying "TRANS INCLUSIONAL FEMINIST"]
NC what do you understand that mean
MC talks about the connection to liberation movements
[we get bogged down in terminology]
NC MD was announcing to the world for whom men who say they are women count as women
MC for whom Trans Women are Women
NC are you saying Trans Women are different from Women
MC there are trans women and trans men and men and women
NC so they're different
MC they are women, they're a type of women
NC so are you upset about her lack of regret
MC there are people who are extremist and there are people who aren't
NC so what did SM say that was toxic
MC I never said she was toxic, I said the event was toxic
NC so if MD attended an event with people holding flags saying if you see a terf, punch them and other toxic messages – if there was would that make MD's association as ill-judged as SM's attendance at LWS
MC it depends what the hypothetical message would be so I can't
… answer that.
NC you are holding SM to an impossibly high standard,
MC the problem is that the central speaker who had said toxic things in the part – such as "Islam… disgusting"
NC and that's SM's failing.
MC "I don't always believe in guilt by association"
NC goes back to his email about standing up for the rights of women and how it is a message for the far right
NC so you're saying that standing up for the rights of women is a far right
MC I'd just made a film about mussolini and met lots of far right men using that phrase
MC "standing up for womens rights" and it was scaring me. I probably shouldn't have put it in the email but I was hearing it a lot.
NC so going back to SM's speech what is wrong with it
MC I didn't like her naming partner organisations. "I have not got a problem with SM having this views, but its sharing them in this context concerned me" MC I was slightly haunted by that phrase – Tommy Robinson uses it as do the anti-immigrant people down south
MC I am a feminist and its the misappropriation of that phrase which is deeply troubling
NC what you are doing is smearing SM with a trope as MD did with her text about SM
MC "well that wasn't MD's finest hour" but she fires off so many jokes in texts, you'll see that I didn't respond with a smiley or anything
MC goes on to say that NC was "so far off beam" with what she suggested to MD yesterday about trying to get SM sacked. "I hadn't even thought of that"
[we go to 4 July – another email from MC about his encounter with SM]
"I'd like formally to tell you about an incident which concerns me as a
board member of Docs Ireland/Belfast Film Festival, and as passionate
believer in our diversity values."
NC why are you doing this again?
MC it was the first time I'd been touched by this personally and I think I want to put this on the record formally as the last email was more casual. "What particularly bothered me was that SM was saying her boss was misrepresenting the situation. I didn't think that was good thing to say that to a board member.
NC you're third point after complaining about the lack of regret SM expressed was "(3) If I remember
correctly, her child is a trans woman, so she is misgendering her here (I might
be wrong about that)."
NC you've never given birth
MC correct
NC do you think a mother might know the sex of the person they have given birth to
MC it's up to the trans person to say who they are and what they are
SD this is a very sensitive are and the C's child has no role in these proceedings
J why is this relevant
NC C has sex realist beliefs. the suggestion is that the R is fully signed up to paying lip service to this belief system and this is about whether C has suffered discrimination
SD it's nothing to do with her child
NC it's directly relevant to the accusation that the R discriminated
J why is it not in the list of issues
NC it's not at the heart of it – but it's relevant evidence – it's in his own WS – I must be entitled to q him on the contents of his own WS
J so what do you want to ask
NC I have a sequence of q's it makes it v difficult to tell you the end point
J give us the gist
NC that's the same question
J I'll allow it to a certain extent, but don't go into social argument again
NC thank you
NC I asked if a mother might give a birth to a boy or a girl
– would she know about the sex of the person
MC there comes a point at which a trans person psychologically in their identity knows who they are –
NC do you accept that the mother/child bond is profoundly powerful
MC yes of course
NC not just for the child but the mother too
MC yes
NC is it not massively authoritarian to change criticise a mother for using the real sex pronouns of her child
MC absolutely not
NC and is shows you were confident in doing this with colleagues on the board
MC absolutely not – I don't know the opinions of the board – you seem to think we had a phalanx of opinion – all lined up
NC we know where you stand, we know where MD stands – you may have GC colleagues, but you don't know who they are, do you?
MC just like I don't know the religion or sexuality of my colleagues
NC the reason you don't know your GC colleagues is that they are frightened
MC no
NC they're worried about expressing their view
MC no – that doesn't sound honest
NC your line about accelerating the process "I therefore feel that we need to accelerate the process by which this is sorted… We can't have an inclusion/diversity officer who, many weeks after making such an ill-advised speech, is still standing by her actions
completely."
NC you're trying to get rid of her
MC no that was my draw drop moment from yesterday
NC you're saying you can't have her as an inclusion officer – what are you going to do – make her the accountant?
MC my problem is her actions – not what she said "speaking in such an extremist context" – if she was going to stand by those actions we couldn't have an inclusion officer doing that. But the idea we were trying to move her out is "rubbish"
[we are taking a 5 minute break – I'll plough on with this thread till lunch as NC told J there was only 10 more mins with MC to go]
If you would like to read the last three days' tweet threads you can find them here:
genderblog.net/live-tweets/
And if… sorry to keep doing this, but if you find any of this useful and would like to get the nightly round up of the day's action (sorry, proceedings), please consider making a small donation here.
genderblog.net/donate/
Last night's took a mere five hours to pull together so they don't tend to come through till quite late, but I did a quick straw poll at the end of it and responses suggest most people prefer a comprehensive write up delivered late to a quick report on the whistle.
[we're back]
NC you said you wanted to pause encounters between groups SM criticised and those groups – that was a pretty sensible idea in the circs
MC imo yes
NC let everything die down
MC let us investigate
NC but don't inflame things
MC that was my opinion, yes
NC – MD's next move was the 3 July email – the email to the LGBTQ crown cc-ing SM including Alliance for Choice – that was one of the groups SM had mentioned in her speech. So this was an email just a few weeks later – what do you think of what MD did given you wanted to pause…
… encounters.
MC I'm a board member – but I heard yesterday something about SM agreeing to it
NC it was extraordinarily ill judged – at best
MC it was an attempt and bridge building and attempt at repair work
NC it didn't go well
MC you can't predict outcomes all the time
NC any fool could have seen this was poking a hornet's nest
MC well maybe I'm a fool then because I've just said I thought it was a bridge building exercise
NC it was obvious this email was going to poke up the hornet's nest – she at first damped things down it did all go quiet and then she sends out this email on 3 July – that was step 1 in the implementation of the "acceleration of the process" that you had called for on 25 June?
MC absolutely not
[go to par 12 of MC's WS]
"I don't understand why she could no-
foresee that, by associating herself with people who have said oppressive things, there would be a reaction "
NC that's a criticism
MC it's bewilderment
NC the whole subject of her speech at that event – was that women need to be able to talk about these things – 'we're being silenced, we're being shouted down and we must be allowed to speak'
MC yes
NC but you're saying that if one group of angry people is going to react to another group of people – they need to learn to shut up
MC not at all
NC your par 12 is a bully's charter isn't it
MC I was bullied at school and I work with a lot of anti-bullying charities and I find that question objectionable
NC could you answer it – is it s bully's charter?
MC absolutely not
[we have split for lunch. we are going to reconvene at 1.45pm to hear the remainder of Michele Devlin's evidence]
I'll start that on a new tweet thread. So that's the end of this one.
Session 2:
65 tweets
Hello and welcome to Day 4 Session 2 of Morrison v BFF. Judge and Panel are here. Here are this morning's tweets.
x.com/nickwallis/status/1988922104742334832?s=20
Good morning and welcome to Killymeal House Belfast for Day 4 Session 1 of Morrison v Belfast Film Festival. Proceedings are due to begin at 11am. It is raining again.

PLEASE BE AWARE EVERYTHING I WRITE IS A SUMMARY AND CHARACTERISATION OF WHAT IS SAID IN COURT. NOTHING IS A DIRECT QUOTE UNLESS IT IS IN "DIRECT QUOTES"
MD – Michele Devlin BFF CEO is giving evidence
Naomi Cunningham (NC) there was a meeting between you, Lisa Barros D'sa and Marie-Therese McGivern but you can't remember anything about it
MD no
[we move on to the documents which MD said she would dig up proving that Pride on the Big Screen (PBS) had been in the planning since Feb 2023]
NC you have provided 145 pages of disclosure this morning
MD yes
NC 37 pages of that are the instruction manual for erecting your Big…
… Screen
MD it may be
[they look at it]
NC that material was never going to give the tribunal the slightest assistance had been in the planning since Feb or was dreamed up on 25 June
MD is that a question
NC I'll run it again [she does]
MD it might help people understand what we do
NC It might help them erect a big screen, but it's not going to help with the issue in hand
MD It might help people understand what we do. We had this screen we were under pressure to use
NC are you really telling the tribunal this will assist them in any task they are trying to perform
MD I don't know, I've never been to a tribunal
NC another 37 pages is an event management plan for something which took place on 15/16 July
MD it's very similar to what we would do for PBS
NC this is a plan for a different event
MD I couldn't find the doc for PBS
MD as I was under oath and couldn't speak to my team
NC so there is an event management plan for PBS somewhere is there
MD absolutely – we had an event management plan for Shellshock Sessions at the Belfast stories site and it would be a question of changing some minor details
[we are in the process of establishing there is no such plan for PBS because…]
MD events overtook and we cancelled it
NC goes to email from Moyra Lock to SM attaching invoices and a couple of emails by return – you're not copied in any of these emails are you – 24 Jan
MD and 16 Jan
NC there's no sign you were copied in any of these emails
MD no
NC if you didn't contact anyone in the BFF – how did you get your hands on them between yesterday and today
MD I must have had them on my laptop
NC how did you get them there
MD I put them there
NC how
MD I have lots of folders on my laptop
SD it's part of the discovery process
NC it's not for SD to give evidence on the part of his client
J what is the q
NC she told you she's not copied to these emails. she has them
NC but can't get the information she wanted
J where did you go to get these emails
MD two laptops – one old and one new
J were these in folders or emails
MD could have been anything
J how did you… get this
MD I was searching both laptops – but without speaking to the administrator I found it very difficult
MD "it was kind of fiddly"
J any more q's NC
NC I think that takes it as far as we need – I am going to take you quickly through this section which doesn't have even arguable relevance
MD I'm sorry it was done very high speed
[NC brings up a discussion note in May 2022 about doing an event at Pride 2022]
MD is giving the tribunal a post-COVID history of BFF's involvement with Pride Belfast (PB)
NC so you're saying in May 2022 it became part of BFF's thinking that there would be an involvement
in Pride each year going forward.
MD yes and I thought the Rainbow Project in 2022 was something Michele was involved with but she wasn't
NC so in May 2022 you discussed…
MD not that event – an ongoing established relationship with PB
NC we go to email of 29 June – so far as documentary record is concerned this is the only evidence of any plans being made for PBS
MD yes
NC and that's the day after the meeting
… you can't remember anything about.
MD if you say so
NC well – if you look at when your 29 June email was sent it's just past midnight – so it's a few hours after your meeting you can't remember anything about [with the incoming co-chairs from memory]
NC how common is it for you to send emails to working partners after midnight
MD very – since the pandemic especially – people send emails at any time
NC lets look at it – it's an invitation to put the Big Screen up at Pride – does it jog your memory about your conversation
… earlier that day.
MD no I'm not trying to be evasive – I just don't remember
NC and you say it's a "tight turnaround" – this has all the hallmarks of something set up in a tearing rush
MD I wouldn't say a tearing rush but it we were heading towards it quite quickly
NC you…
… said this had been months in the planning. Where are the emails from you to SM saying come on we need to hurry this along
MD we are in an open plan office we have lots of conversations
NC the reality is – this doc you disclosed with a load of irrelevant info that C could
is the most compelling evidence [sorry] that the C could wish for that you cooked up this event in order to orchestrate a pile on
MD I don't accept that
NC that was a thoroughly dishonest way to behave wasn't it
MD no
NC you saw how the pile on affected her
MD I supported her…
… for many weeks.
NC and you deliberately put her back into the firing line
MD she told me it had all calmed down
NC you must have known the risk
MD "possibly", but if you look at the email list there are a lot of individuals who are award-winning film-makers
[MD goes into a long explanation as to why using the Big Screen was imperative to their operation and sponsors]
NC in dreaming up that event on 25 June – "it was a deliberate ploy to reignite the storm – it was a reckless risk with Sara's health and wellbeing"
MD no – "this could have been seen as a bridge-building moment, because there were a lot of groups that Sara got on with". She didn't say anything transphobic in the her speech she said it had all calmed down – this could have been a happy moment.
NC you knew she didn't want to send the email
MD that was because of the Alliance in Action
NC you knew she was was frightened
MD no
NC she was rightly frightened "and your action in doing this was cruel, wasn't it?
MD I don't accept that for one minute"
[moves to another doc]
NC on 7 July you get the permission that you need to put PBS event on from council for an event on 30 July.
MD yes
NC and then I think we see it somewhere – you'll agree the pencilled tent booking was made and then you cancelled it – and the reality is…
… you knew it wasn't going to happen – you and SM were both on holiday for two weeks
MD I was on holiday for 1 week, SM was on holiday for 2 weeks
J I think you said 7 – 20 July
MD the holiday dates are irrelevant because once we initiate them they are run by our freelance…
… team with oversight from one staff member.
NC you're not naive about social media
MD nope. I'm not naive about anything
NC you were savvy enough to hide the reply tweet re SM on 18 April
MD after speaking to my marketing manager – she broiught it to my attention
NC you did an efficient job of damping down the aftermath of the LWS event
MD "the reputational damage was unprecedented" I had to look after my team
NC so are you really asking us to believe that when you sent that email on 3 July you didn't know what was going to happen
MD I was shocked [talks about abuse she's had from people supporting SM's crowdfunder and how she's stepped away from social media since then]
NC MC is an important charismatic member of your board. Influential.
MD all our board are
NC on 25 June MC sets the ball rolling, on 28 June in the meeting no one can recall you work out how to set the process in motion and send the first email on 29 June
MD no we needed to use the Big Screen
NC the screen had been used once before in Docs Ireland
NC and then on 3 July you send the email which caused all the fuss
MD no there is no process or plan this is rubbish
NC and that's why there is no paper trail at all about setting up PBS
MD no
NC and you have this meeting with your board members which you say you can't remember, but you can remember it and it's where you cook up the plan
NC quite striking that no one can remember what happened at the meeting on 28 June isn't it?
MD doesn't answer
NC and that's why there's no planning of the event until the small hours of 29 June
MD is that a question?
NC yes
MD no
NC indicates she is going to move on
J are you okay Ms D – do you need a break
MD no I'm dead on
NC so on 4 July mid-morning you email MTM and LBD to tell them you are implementing the plan you came up with
MD I reject your language – there was no plan – I did send an email
NC why report back to them – this was pretty routine
MD no
NC please don't interrupt
MD sorry
NC what was special about this
MD we had just had a complicated period of time in April or whenever it was
NC are you saying it was becuase you knew of the sensitivities aroiund SM's contact with the LGBTQ peopel on that list
… that you were reporting back to them.
MD yeah I thought there might be one or two people who might have reacted. SM told it would be fine. and I thought it would be okay "maybe I'm overly optimistic about human nature"
NC in your email you have an on way of referring to…
… Alliance for Choice.
MD I honestly believe the only thing we would get back is maybe a complaint from AfC
NC you call that email confidential – why
MD somethings are
NC it's confidential 1 – was there any more traffic on that thread
MD I don't know
NC SM said this was another
test. Like asking if she would share a toilet with a transwoman or starting an LBGTQ project with Kabosh.
"it was a deliberate stirring up of trouble for her"
MD n. "all along with those whole process that there were no issues, that everything had passed that she had no problem working with LGBT orgs so I proceeded assuming she would do her job in the same way."
NC we go to Queerspace's response to MD's 3 July email:
"We take the safety of our members seriously and are very concerned by one aspect
of this event. We have trans people in our group, as well as a strong history of trans
inclusion. In your email, you have copied a member of Belfast Film Festival staff who
spoke at the “Posie Parker” rally in Belfast. Her speech is available online and the
content is distressing. She spoke openly against Trans rights."
NC they accuse her of transphobia
MD they say she spoke openly of trans rights
NC same thing
MD no it's not. and language is important in this debate "they say she spoke openly against trans rights…. I took it as a criticism of us"
NC Queerspace are not an organisation mentioned by SM in her speech are they?
MD no
NC and Ruth from Outburst Arts joins in with the condemnation "In April this year, Sara Morrison^ Equality and Inclusion Officer for Belfast Film Festival who you have copied in here,
spoke openly at an anti-trans event in Belfast."
NC so the fact that you have copied her in to your 3 July email is noted
MD I don't think it would have made any difference
NC asks her to read the rest of the email
MD asks for a break
J says we'll have a break then MD can read the email and we'll reconvene in 10 minutes.
Full email is as follows:
"On 4 Jul 2023, at 09:28, Outburst Arts wrote:
Dear Michele,
In April this year, Sara Morrison Equality and Inclusion Officer for Belfast Film Festival who you have copied in here, spoke openly at an anti-trans event in Belfast.
She spoke on the same platform as Jolene Bunting, a Britain First fascist who is proudly anti gay. anti abortion, anti Catholic and anti migrant. Jolene Bunting was. also recently taken to court by local gay drag perform er and regular Outburst contributor Matthew Cavan, who she labelled as a paedophile and harassed repeatedly while encouraging others to do the same.
In addition to legitimising an anti-gay fascist, Sara stood on the same platform and. legitimised anti trans campaigner Posie Parker, who organised the event. Posie Parker is an anti-queer crusader who has been touring her circus around the world and building anti-trans sentiment that has caused and continues to cause massive damage, not only trans people but to LGBT people across the board and especially those living in the most precarious economic and political circumstances.
The anti-trans and anti-LGBT discourse that is perpetuated by events such as the one that Sara lent her voice to, are impacting on the safety and well-being of real people. We have Worked with vulnerable trans and queer people and lesbian women in 27 countries globally who are being battered by this growing right-wing discourse, human beings who are our friends, family, team members, arts network, our support and people we love. At Outburst we see every day the damage that this discourse is responsible for and it is terrifying. I will always champion freedom of expression and freedom of speech, especially in art, and have no interest in silencing intelligent open discourse.
There is however a world of difference between generous, kind and brave space for exchange – a space that we work hard for Outburst to be – and legitimising and adding to dangerous and damaging anti LGBT rhetoric. To receive an email where Sara is included as someone we are invited to organise an LGBT event with on behalf of Belfast Film Festival, feels deeply inappropriate. We unreservedly applaud Pride’s decision this year to centre trans rights. We are in this together or we are lost. Things have become too dangerous and if we are not part of the solution, not part of intelligently building trust, kindness and solidarity instead of firing up division like Sara has done, then we are part of the problem.
Yours sincerely
Ruth McCarthy
Artistic Director, Outburst Arts"
[we're back – looking at the above email]
NC we see RM joining. She monsters Sara – she accuses her of legitimising fascists and the far right
MD I did not read it that way
NC she accuses her of firing up division. Having re-read this in the break – it's fair to say she's labelling a transphobe
MD no there's lots of ways – you can be transphobic or trans critical
NC the gist is that her email is transphobic
MD I am reluctant to paraphrase
NC there is no mention of womens orgs here
MD no – it's a queer arts org
NC not one of the womens orgs named in SM's speech
MD no
NC we see another email saying "I would like to echo Queerspace and Outburst emails." – this means that QS and OB sent their emails as reply alls haven't they?
MD no not nec
NC how did it happen then
MD she may have just cc'd some people – a lot of these people work together
J is it feasible
MD I don't remember
NC we don't see this in the disclosure
MD no
NC you open copied everyone in that initial 3 July you sent
MD in error
NC no it was a tactic to make it easier for recipients to continue the convo
MD I dont' accept that
NC but it had that effect as Katrin Coover [sp?] was able to echo what QS and OB had said
MD it seems so yes
NC and she works for Ardoyne which is a youth group – not a women's group
MD it works across sectors – including womens' groups and LGBT
NC but it's not specifically a
… women's group.
MD it works across sectors
NC but it wasn't mentioned in SM's speech
[we move to another email]
This is from Sarah Williams from Outburst writing in a personal capacity:
"Your email and invitation to connect with colleagues across the LGBT sector of Belfast is of
course wonderful and indeed welcomed. Working collegiately is at the core of everything I do,
and is a value I hold dear. In different circumstances, I would welcome the opportunity to help cocreate
something which would add value to the experience of the Belfast Pride weekend. So in
light of this, I am writing to you as a colleague in the sector.
It is no surprise to you, to know that a member of your team holds, and publicly shares, negative
opinions about Trans people. To invite us to co-create an event for Belfast Pride with this team
member, came as quite a shock. Trans rights is a central theme to the Pride celebrations this
year, and to invite trans inclusive organisations to work with this individual, without addressing the very public and very dangerous opinions she holds while in the position of being your
Inclusion Officer, is not something I can be part of or endorse.
As individuals, we all of course hold our own opinions on all matters and difference of opinion is
never something I shy away from. And sometimes agreeing to disagree with mutual respect is
achievable. But when such opinions quite literally impact the health and well-being of people I
hold dear, I cannot come to the table unless there is a willingness to acknowledge the damage
caused by your Inclusion Officer, not only at the Posie Parker public event, but also the instances
of transphobic comments and behaviour in her capacity as a team member of the Film Festival.
I appreciate that this is a difficult and delicate issue to balance as the leader of your organisation.
Please know that what I am sharing here, is coming from a place of care and respect for the work
you and your team do.
Sarah"
[MD is reading the email through]
MD the third par in that email is the one which most resonates with me –
"As individuals, we all of course hold our own opinions on all matters and difference of opinion is
never something I shy away from. And sometimes agreeing to disagree with mutual respect is
achievable. But when such opinions quite literally impact the health and well-being of people I
hold dear, I cannot come to the table unless there is a willingness to acknowledge the damage
caused by your Inclusion Officer, not only at the Posie Parker public event, but also the instances
of transphobic comments and behaviour in her capacity as a team member of the Film Festival."
NC yes it's different in tone – "more in sorrow than anger" – she accuses SM of being transphobic
MD it's about working together
NC yes but her saying SM holds neg opinions about trans people – is that right
MD I don't know
NC you've heard the speech
MD that's not her whole psyche
SD there is no reference to the speech – it's just what she's said – who knows what else she's said
J we can't really impute what she meant without asking her
NC but I can ask MD what she reads into it
NC she's complaining about SM's opinions, isn't she
"very public and very dangerous opinions" and "when such opinions…" – she's talking about SM's opinions
NC she is specifically complaining about SM's dangerous opinions
MD they could be in any environment – they aren't necessarily about the rally. That could be alluding to anything
NC this is not a complaint you have to take seriously is it
MD of course i do
NC she's complaining about dangerous opinions
NC you can't police peoples' thoughts can you
MD no I wou;dn't want to
NC literally dangerous – "it's obvious nonsense isn't it – it's hysterical"
MD "no its not hysterical – it's her opinion"
[we move on]
NC and you have not come up with any examples beyond a shared board member and some minor work with Alliance for Choice.
MD I was told to keep things to a minimum in my WS – I can give you lots and lots of examples of having worked with many organisations. [she does so]
MD I probably have about 50 or more [examples] – you could just look through the work we've done over the last 25 years, as SM should have done. There's a whole bundle I've got.
NC you are trying to show us that you have done lots of work and all you've got is work you did in…
… 2013
MD I've got loads I can give you
NC you've had your chance
MD [laughs – gives long list of women's groups BFF has worked with in the past]
[we move on]
NC look at 5 July email to board:
"I am sending you a note to flag up an issue which has emerged over the past few days, regarding a member of our
staff speaking at a rally in Belfast in April this year.
I have been liaising with the Chair/s to resolve this matter -1 know some of you are aware from social media and
conversations you have had with your own friends and colleagues. The chair/s and I are drafting a statement which
will go out today. I will run it by you all in advance so would appreciate it if you could cast your eye over it before it
goes public.
Michele"
NC This wasn't something about past few days – this happened yesterday – 4 July.
MD well yesterday and today – that's two days. I just wanted to make sure they knew
NC well it was on 28 June that you got together to work out what to do to "accelerate the process"
MD "no it's just a turn of phrase… the last two days.. the last day or two…"
This is an email on 4 July sent to MTM and LBD to her co-chairs "Hi Marie-Therese and Louise
Yesterday we sent this email to all LGBTQ groups on our database, I worked with Sara to draw up the
list and we jointly wrote this email. Sara was concerned about sending it from her email address,
because of an issue she had with Alliance forChoice-ltoldheritwasherjobasinclusion officer that
it should come from her, but if it would help I would send it from my email address and cc her in.
We have had a few positive emails back. And we have had 2 others which I will forward to you
separately. We have also had some tweets from Queerspace – which I will send to you FYI.
Michele
Dear LGBTQI+ Friends
"We are looking forward to Pride 2023 and are currently planning a PRIDE ON THE BIG SCREEN chillout
day at the new Belfast Stories site – opposite the Sunflower (Union St / Kent St). Following the
success of the Shellshock Sessions event at this exciting new site during our Doc Festival in June (see
below). Unfortunately, in June we were choc-a-block so didn’t get time to submit to the pride
brochure.
We want the film day to be a relaxing affair for those who want to nurse their hangover on one of our
beanbags … or get out of the house with the kids – we are thinking of starting with x2 family films …
maybe the Wizard of Oz / Encanto??. And of including some short films made by local LGBTQI+
filmmakers (Conan McIver's brilliant Dam?). Pedro has put his oar in for PRIDE the film. Maybe
nothing with subtitles, coz we all might be feeling a bit delicate on the Sunday. We would love the
opportunity to co-design this day with you, time is tight… we would be happy to meet / chat with you
this week … it would be great it if you could give us a ring/drop us a note with your thoughts /
ideas. Please share to groups/individuals we may have missed. In Solidarity and with Pride
Michele Devlin
Director
Belfast Film Festival
& Docs Ireland
NC where are the positive emails of support
MD mentions a few off the top of her head
NC they haven't been disclosed
MD that's correct
NC all we know about those emails is that R has chosen not to disclose it
MD I haven't. I just told you
NC all we've seen is a few complaints
… not from women's sector.
MD yes
NC there might be dozens of emails saying well done for not bowing to the mob
MD there are two or three
NC saying that
MD not saying that – just saying how much they support the event
NC but not important enough to put in your WS
MC there's a lot in my WS. [x] pages. "It could put you to sleep"
NC the 3 July email went to two orgs mentioned in SM's speech and they did not complain
MD i didn't get any complaints
NC so there is no evidence whatsoever that SM's crit of womens' orgs in a private capacity has generated complaints and there is no evidence it damaged BFF's reputation at all
MD based on that analysis, no
NC so the decision to investigate SM came from the 3 emails sent from two orgs
MD there was tonnes on SM
NC before 5 July?
MD more after
NC but that's when the investigation was launched
MD there was loads of stuff before – we new we had to investigate fro 16 April
NC so are you saying that the investigation was sparked by what happened on 16 April
MD yes
NC why not get Think People investigation on 4 May board meeting, or 25 May email from MC?
MD I didn't want to disrupt the team
NC what about 25 June when MC wanted to "accelerate the process"
MD I was already in contact with Think People
NC and you knew you didn't have what you need to get rid of SM until it flared up again on 3 July.
sorry should add NC said something about – because of the advice you have taken
MD I could have disciplined SM at any time and I was going to talk to her, but I knew I had to speak to her and I was going to speak to her but we're a small team and it was a busy time
NC you're saying at some point when you got around to it after 16 April and there was nothing about what happened on 3 and 4 July to engage Think People on the 5th.
MD I needed space and time for both SM and me to consider and think about it
NC and is the reason you didn't do anything on 18 April – when you had all the facts
MD I didn't have all the facts
NC so was that not enough
MD another thing that emerged was the convo with the filmmaker
NC is this Caleb
MD yes
NC we'll come back to that tomorrow
NC none of those complaints on 4 and 5 July have anything to do with SM's criticism of women's groups
NC they were about transphobia
MD none of them said anything about transphobia
NC she was guilty of wrongthink
MD what's that
NC having dangerous opinions
MD I've never heard of wrongthink in my life
NC that's why I said dangerous opinions
MD can we stick to what's said in the emails
NC dangerous opinions is in the email
MD I want to get the language in this right. the right language is important in this debate.
[NC wants to move on but J notes the time. Big discussion about tomorrow. It looks like MD is going to be in the chair for 2 hours more. I don't think we're starting until 11.30am tomorrow, so we're going to have MD for most of tomorrow and perhaps one other witness]
Sorry. Rushed out to get some photos. Now closing down the thread with the usual messages. Thanks v much for reading this far. If you…
… would like to make even a tiny one-off contribution you’ll get the nightly newsletter summary of each day’s proceedings going forward:
genderblog.net/donate/
I am going back to my spartan lodgings to write tonight’s before we reconvene at 1130 tomorrow.
Adieu. End of 🧵

