Sara Morrison v Belfast Film Festival Tribunal – Day 8

Live Tweets

Live tweets from Day 8 of the Sara Morrison v Belfast Film Festival employment tribunal.

Session 1:

83 tweets

Welcome to Killymeal House for Day 8 Session 1 of Morrison v Belfast Film Festival. Live tweets follow

Please note nothing I tweet is verbatim unless it is in "direct quotes". My tweets are a summary and/or characterisation of what is being said in court.

This is scheduled to be the last day of evidence. We are expecting three Belfast Film Festival (BFF) witnesses today starting with Lisa Barros D'Sa (LB) who has just been sworn in. She is a co-chair of the BFF.

Naomi Cunningham (NC) will be cross-examining (xe) LB and Sean Doherty (SD) will be re-examining for the BFF.
NC morning LB
LB morning!
NC takes LB to her witness statement (WS): "Many groups in the women's
sector had criticised the input from the Claimant at this rally"

NC is that true
LB I was told thath
NC who told you that
LB Lucy Baxter
NC which groups
LB can't remember
NC "were specific groups mentioned or was it just "many groups""
LB I can't recall that

NC takes her to redacted board meeting minutes from 4 May 2023 "the input from BFF I LAD Co-ordinator was a criticism of many groups in the women's sector"
NC you've just lifted that statement
LB no
NC or whoever wrote it did
LB I wrote my own statement

NC did you watch SM's speech [at Let Women Speak LWS – 1hr 4min in here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-LF5Nn-rNfY]
LB yes

LB yes
NC have a read of it now
LB the women's groups that SM was criticising were part of the Songs for Solidarity event which were trying to drown LWS out
SD where's that in evidence
NC it's on the face of the document
NC "they are here to silence women"

NC were you aware that's what the complaint was
LB I was aware many groups had been mentioned, when I listened to the speech and I learned the context they had been mentioned
NC there had been quite a lot of chatter on soc med before the event – anti-fascist and pro-trans

… groups encouraging each other to attend the event
LB I wasn't aware of that.

[NC takes her docs in the bundle which she thinks prove her point]
NC do you accept there was chatter
LB [mishear]
NC "and you accept that one of those groups is Alliance for Choice?"
LB "I can see that there, yes"

NC it's clear that what SM is complaining about in her speech is that the groups present are there "to shame and silence women"
LB "I can tell that SM is speaking in criticism of those groups and she has every right to do so as a private citizen…

… – where it becomes and issue for the FF is when it intersects" with criticism of our organisation – I have no problem with her speaking up for her political beliefs

NC what's the problem with what she said
LB when it first came up in the board meeting it came up as
NC "do you understand the difference between reputational damage and people making unjustified crits of you?"

LB at this point it was something that was being experienced – "I make no judgment as to whether it was legitimate or justified" – that it was happening
NC the board did nothing at that point did it?
LB the next day Michele (Devlin – MD – BFF CEO) and Marie-Therese McGivern (co-

… chair of the BFF – MTM) and we decided to call the Equality Commission (EC) and look at whether "this came into conflict with Sara's employment… and exploring the situation which had arisen"

NC Reputational Damage (RD) is about justified criticism?
LB and how it affects an or
NC what examples did you see

LB "there was a sense that there were associations with… groups that disrecpted trans people that gave concern to some people… at least one person mentioned thaht in the email that MD sent to us. I know

that Lucy had mentioned womens groups, so those are the areas that I believe had been mentioned at that stage."

NC the women speaking at LWS had real concerns
LB they did
NC single sex toilets, men in rape crisis centres, induced lactation in men, mutilating young bodies
LB can't speculate

NC what I'm trying to establish is that these are real important matters
LB I have no problem with people speaking about important things that they infringe on peoples' rights

NC so womens' groups trying to shut other women down for expressing those views they deserve criticism
LB speaking out is fine, but if it starts to cause reputational damage then its understandable people would want to explore
NC if women's orgs are trying to silence other women for speaking about serious
LB "I can't speak to their moral compass"
NC and BFF trying to say we can't speak about these things is "cowardly and unprincipled"
LB I don't think that was what was being said
NC it's not about women's groups tho, is it really – it's about SM speaking out about gender critical issues
LB it was that she had aligned herself with groups widely perceived to be transphobic and that troubled some people in the trans community
NC yes so it was about her alignment with view which were not approved
LB I think it can be both those things can be true – there wasn't any sense she wasn't allowed to say it. There were just aspects which clashed with the BFF's approach
NC you haven't looked me in the eye throughout all those questions
SD this is not relevant
J why asking
NC I want to know why she's doing this
J she doesn't have to. are you saying it's disrespectful
NC her demeanour is part of her evidence
J [to LB] do you want to comment on this
SD interjects – it's common for a witness not to look
LB I'm just trying to think clearly
J do you want to make an application
NC I don't want the tribunal to make her look me in the eye – I'm just drawing it to the tribunals attn
NC we don't tend to make free with crit of our friends – there is the right time
LB yes
NC but it's not true friendship to watch your friends behaving badly and say nothing
LB that seems subjective
NC and at the political scale where we say our friends are our friends and no matter how badly they behaved we're not going to crit them
LB the groups were groups the BFF had been working with for some time
NC so that means it's okay not to crit them
LB "complaints were received… they had not been investigated as to their validity. That was to come"
NC groups don't like being criticised and if they are crit they may complain, but it doesn't nec mean anyone has done anything wrong
LB it meant they needed to be investigated, I don't think anyone had made a judgment that anyone had done anything wrong
NC for Alliance for Choice to join in an effort to "drown out women's voices" was "deplorable"
LB no I don;t know why they did it
NC and if one of your employees took issue with it – it should be brushed off
LB no- complaints should be investigated
NC if your friends are going to abandon you for speakig the truth according to your conscience – they're not friends worth having"
LB I would say probably not

NC arts are important
LB yes of course they're important
NC and it's important for an org like BFF to have integrity
LB complaints and been received and they had to be looked at as part of an investigation

NC turning to the chronology (chron) – this first came to your attn at 4 May board meeting
LB yes
NC then MD sent an email on 5 May

NC you saw that the same day
NC you say at par 4 of your WS "The Respondent organisation has a
long-standing reputation for supporting LGBTQ+ rights, therefore I was worried that
Belfast Film Festival would suffer consequences."

NC should the tribunal conclude from that that you fear that by speaking at LWS, SM would seem to be opposing LGBTQ+ rights
LB potentially
NC that seems to be what you're saying there – there's something that might damage that rep

LB yes
NC and that's what's borne out by her critics [NC takes her to the bundle. Ruth McCarthy 4 July email "In April this year, Sara Morrison,
Equality and Inclusion Officer for
Belfast Film Festival who you
have copied in here, spoke openly
at an anti-trans event in Belfast.
She spoke on the same platform
as Jolene Bunting, a Britain First
fascist who is proudly anti gay,
anti abortion, anti Catholic and
anti migrant. Jolene Bunting was
also recently taken to court by
local gay drag performer and
regular Outburst contributor
Matthew Cavan, who she labelled
as a paedophile and harassed
repeatedly while encouraging
others to do the same.
In addition to legitimising an anti-
gay fascist, Sara stood on the
same platform and legitimised anti
trans campaigner Posie Parker, who organised the event. Posie
Parker is an anti queer crusader
who has been touring her circus
around the world and building anti
trans sentiment that has caused
and continues to cause massive
damage, not only trans people but
to LGBT people across the board
and especially those living in the
most precarious economic and
political circumstances.
The anti-trans and anti-LGBT
discourse that is perpetuated by
events such as the one that Sara
lent her voice to, are impacting on
the safety and well-being of real
people. We have worked with
vulnerable trans and queer people
and lesbian women in 27
countries globally who are being
battered by this growing rightwing
discourse, human beings
who are our friends, family, team
members, arts network, our
support and people we love.
At Outburst we see every day the
damage that this discourse is
responsible for and it is terrifying.
I will always champion freedom of
expression and freedom of
speech, especially in art, and
have no interest in silencing
intelligent open discourse.
There is however a world of
difference between generous,
kind and brave space for
exchange – a space that we work
hard for Outburst to be – and
legitimising and adding to
dangerous and damaging anti
LGBT rhetoric. To receive an email where Sara is
included as someone we are
invited to organise an LGBT event
with on behalf of Belfast Film
Festival, feels deeply
inappropriate.
We unreservedly applaud Pride’s
decision this year to centre trans
rights.
We are in this together or we are
lost.
Things have become too
dangerous and if we are not part
of the solution, not part of
intelligently building trust,
kindness and solidarity instead of
firing up division like Sara has
done, then we are part of the
problem."

NC this speaks to the idea that SM was aligning herself with transphobia
LB yes I think that's the indication

[NC takes her to the Queerspace email: "We take the safety of our members seriously and are very concerned by one aspect
of this event. We have trans people in our group, as well as a strong history of trans
inclusion. In your email, you have copied a member of Belfast Film Festival staff who
spoke at the “Posie Parker” rally in Belfast. Her speech is available online and the
content is distressing. She spoke openly against Trans rights…

"Queerspace, as a trans-inclusive organisation, as part of Belfast Pride, whose theme
is “Stand by your Trans” would like to know one simple question:
Will Trans people be treated with dignity and respect at your event?
It is a matter for you who you employ and who you select to organise events.
However, if trans people are not welcome, I’m afraid we are not welcome."

NC so again the nature of that complaint is that by speaking at that event and what she said SM was transphobic and trans people will not be safe at her event
LB they're asking if trans people will be safe
NC is that fair

LB it was a complaint – I make no judgment on the fairness of it
NC and where it says spoke openly against trans rights, did she
LB no she did not speak against trans rights.

NC takes her to the Sarah Williams email
""It is no surprise to you, to know that a member of your team holds, and publicly
shares, negative opinions about Trans people."
NC there were no neg opinions about trans people in SM's speech were there?
LB not in SM's speech no

NC where else
LB I don't know I'm just trying to be specific
NC keeps reading: "As individuals, we all of course hold our own opinions on all matters and difference of
opinion is never something I shy away from and sometimes agreeing to disagree with
mutual respect is achievable. But when such opinions quite literally impact the health
and wellbeing of people I hold dear, I cannot come to the table unless there is a
willingness to acknowledge the damage caused by your Inclusion Officer, not only at
the Posie Parker event, but also the instances of transphobic comments and
behaviour in her capacity as a team member of the Film Festival."

NC so again this is all about transphobia on SM's part isnt' it
LB yes
NC it's all overheated isn't it
LB can't comment, but she's talking about other instances too

NC "But when such opinions quite literally impact the health and wellbeing of people I hold dear," – "that's pretty hysterical isn't it?"
LB can't comment on what she's talking about there.

[NC has used the word "hysterical" three times in this tribunal]

NC takes her to the Lola Petticrew email: "Hello,
My name is Lola Petticrew. I am an actor form Belfast. I took part in
the Belfast film festival a few years ago with a film called a bump
along the way and I felt so privileged to be able to take part in my
home towns film festival. Also safe.
I hope to continue to get to show work there in the future. I love
making working at home and showing work at home and allot the beautiful
things that make up the film industry at home.
However it has recently been brought to-my attention that your inclusion
officer Sara Morrison spoke at a transphobic rally which took place in
Belfast. It has also come to my attention that Belfast Film Festival is
aware of this. I just want to ask how you think someone who is known to
hold transphobic views could possibly hold the position of inclusion…

… officer? I've also been made aware she is a part of events being held
in conjunction with pride? I find this to be absolutely unbelievable to
be honest. Looking at her social media and seeing pages that she follows
which spew vile and vitriolic hate towards trans people also shows how
absolutely wrong it is for her to possibly hold the position of
inclusion officer. Would you have someone who held homophobic views hold
the position of inclusion officer? Or sexist views? Why is it then okay
for an inclusion officer to hold transphobic views? And the idea that
then they would be involved in anything to do with pride just very much
blows my mind. As a trans non binary person working in the industry and
from Belfast-! am deeply saddened and very hurt and concerned. I do hot
at all feel like Belfast film festival is anyway a safe space
considering the information which has been brought to my attention.
Which is not just a real shame and pity but also not at all what I
thought the core values of the Belfast film festival were.
Really looking forward to hearing back from you soon
Lola Petti crew
Lola PetticrewThey/them"

NC again this is all allegations about transphobia, isnt' it
LB yes
[NC takes her to some tweets: "Would
Sunflower consider pulling
the pub as a venue for this
event given the blatant
transphobia that Sara
displayed"]
NC again, all about transphobia
LB yes

[takes LB to a Niall Donnelly email of 6 July: "I have recently become aware of her very public transphobic
views, which I believe are completely unacceptable for someone in this
position.
I have been made aware of her views through a number of sources… I believe that these views are completely inconsistent with the role of
Inclusion Officer… I am therefore demanding that an investigation take place into her views
and current role."]
NC "again that was all about transphobia"
LB "he mentions other instances of transphobic views that he ascribes to Sara"

[he does in this section: "along with specific transphobic social media pages she follows and
seems to interact with. In these instances, she has made derogatory
comments about transgender people, and has expressed the belief that
transgender people are not valid, somethingto be opposed or mocked."]

NC there's a pattern of people being "made aware"
LB I wouldn't say there's nec a pattern – people are aware
NC does it suggest a "certain element of orchestration"
LB not nec – it might be a "growing awareness"

NC Lola Petticrew is making an allegation of transphobia in SM
LB she says: "Sara Morrison spoke at a transphobic rally which took place in
Belfast."

NC LP also says: "Looking at her social media and seeing pages that she follows
which spew vile and vitriolic hate towards trans people also shows how
absolutely wrong it is for her to possibly hold the position of
inclusion officer."

NC now if there was doc evidence of SM's transphobia, it would be in the bundle
LB there is evidence from a young film-maker who says his experience of SM was that she was transphobic
NC we'll come to that in a minute

NC takes her to a "NO TERFS ON OUR TURF" flyer
NC all the communications we've just looked reflect that
LB don't think so
NC that any woman who dares manifest sex realist or gc beliefs need to be driven out of our society
LB I don't think that;s right

NC and par 4 of your WS confirms SM "had the temerity to manifest her sex realist belief in public" and that's what worried you
LB no that's not what I'm saying there
NC and you as an org have done your very best to dress up your concerns as crit of women's groups as that is something you could legit investigate and disc her for
LB no
NC the evidence of transphobia just isn't there, nor is there evidence of damage to reputation through the women's sector orgs that SM had criticised
LB it was a concern. and there was the concern about the context in which SM had spoken
NC there is nothing in the bundle you can point to where anyone in the women's sector criticises SM for what she said
LB I don't see anything

Here is the No Terfs flyer

NC takes her to Mark Cousins (MC) email to her and MTM as a BFF board member: "As a board member I'd like to back you in whatever investigation or process is happening. I
know the staff member in question has a personal family story here – and I like her a lot –
but the principle is clear. Cultural festivals are, amongst other things, acts of solidarity
I with our fellow citizens, especially those whose rights are still contested."

NC he's supporting you – he's a charismatic figure in the BFF and important
LB everyone on the board is important
NC and we see MTM's reply to MC: "So lovely to hear from you and feel your support. Michelle has done all the heavy lifting
here dealing directly with the individual showing support while underlining the points
you make. She was straight on to the Equality Commission and got good advice which
we are actioning. She also took the opportunity of the Docs launch to underline in all
our Comms our commitmentto inclusivity and diversity. Lisa has also been a great
support reflecting in a very insightful way. So your words of advice are most welcome-
it’s good to know we are all United in this situation.
It will take a bit of work to sort this completely but we are already on the right track."

NC "sorting this" means we're all on board with getting rid of SM
LB no it's about putting in place a process to do things properly
NC nothing much happens for a month and then [takes LB to another email]

[this is the MC email about his encounter with SM in a bar: "There was no hint of regret for, or doubt about, what
she did. As you'll know "I'm standing up for the rights of women" is the
argument used by conservatives and religious people in several countries,
and a new staple of the anti-LGBTQanti-lslamic right."]

NC he's ramping things up here. and if standing up for the rights of women is characterised in this way it makes it v hard to stand up for women's rights at all.
LB he's spoken about that in his evidence. "what concerned me is that an employee had been speaking in what sounded like an unprofessional way with festival guests around"

NC MC is speaking about anti-trans stuff again and in the last par he says we need to accelerate the process
LB "that's what he says, yeah"
NC and his last two lines: "We can't have an inclusion/diversity officer who, many
weeks after making such an ill-advised speech, is still standing by her actions
completely." – that's where this is headed isn't it you can't have an inclusion officer who says this she's got to go
LB no I don't think so – he's talking about the Hearth project – I can't say what he means
NC this is the charismatic, outgoing chair…

… and he's saying we can't have an inclusionn and diversity officer with these views – he's saying "get this sorted" to you
LB no I don't think that's the case – he's reporting a concerning event "what sounded inappropriate behaviour of an employee with festival guests around"

NC and your reply "I agree that this situation with Sara grows rather more than less
concerning.
We can’t leave things as they are. Michele/MT let’s have a chat tomorrow? Again
apologies for being late to this."

NC so you say right we better crack on
LB I was responding to the description of the events described which I thought were pretty concerning
NC you apologise for taking two days to reply and you are indicating a willingness to do what he said
LB

… no
NC so you say to MTM you will have a chat. How did that work – 2 sep calls or a three-way chat
LB can't really remember – "it felt like there were serious matters worth considering" "there was at least one phone call"
J were they both on the call
LB can't quite remember

… they might have both been on the call it might have been separate calls. it was def on the phone as I wasn't in the country.
NC and you say in your WS par 6: "I conveyed
my growing concern in my response to Mark and arranged to discuss the matter
further with Marie-Therese and Michele the following day, which I did by
phone call."

NC can't remember how it happened?
LB no I honestly can't remember
NC the concerns were well-established – wasn't this an occasion to decide what to do nex
LB "no this was an occasion to discuss what was a concerning occurrence"
NC you're all busy people
LB yes

NC you get things done
LB yes
NC you set up a phone call, quite urgently, in response to MC saying something needs to be done, and then you have a "hand-wringing session"
LB "we were taking the temp of sit which had been escalating – this was a new bit of info we had to discuss and we discussed it as concerning"

NC you felt you were in a crisis
LB "I'm not descriging it as a crisis – it was a concern"
NC so you decide what to do next
LB talking about our concern

NC so you discussed your concerns and decided to leave it there, is that right
LB can't really remember
NC next thing in your statement is message from MD on 4 July
LB yes
NC so are you saying inbetween your meeting on 28 June and the email on 4 July, nothing was decided about the situation

LB I was packing up to leave London
NC you were too busy
LB "no not too busy… this was an ongoing situation that needed to be considered and it was being considered"
NC okay let's go to 4 July email where MD updates you

[it's the one where she shared the email she sent on 3 July with LB and MTM and the feedback]
NC odd to be told about this routine event
"Hi Marie-Therese and Louise
Yesterday we sent this email to all LGBTQ groups on our database, I worked with Sara to draw up the
list and we jointly wrote this email. Sara was concerned about sending it from her email address,
because of an issue she had with Alliance forChoice-ltoldheritwasherjobasinclusion officer that
it should come from her, but if it would help I would send it from my email address and cc her in."

NC odd that MD framed as an issue with Alliance for Choice
LB not really
NC it would potentially be an issue for SM given what had happened to her
LB can't speak to what MD meant, but it didn't strike me as odd at the time

NC at par 7 of your statement re the 3 July email and response you say: "Michele forwarded to me complaints
received from many organisations in response to her invitation." How many?
LB can't remember
NC how many is many? More than 10
LB three? more than one is sig
NC what's the lowest number you'd think of as "many"
LB "three I think in that context"

NC nobody refers to three as many – you're trying to exaggerate
LB no not in that context, it's a small sector, small city
NC anyway you're saying – three or more complaints – MD says she'll send you two complaints she's received
two is not many
LB I think that's fair – two is two

[we take a break]
[Court is full today – lots of people supporting BFF and SM]

If these tweets are of any use to you and you'd like to get a full round up in my newsletter tonight – pls consider a small one-off donation which gets you added permanently to the list. I'll be following this…

genderblog.net/donate/

… case to its conclusion, which currently means today's hearing, Friday's closing submissions and the ruling, whenever that happens. That will be published online, rather than physically handed down, but depending on which way it goes and whether either party appeals…

… could see further legal battles.

Pls note at the moment there is no scheduled hearing tomorrow, which means there won't be any live-tweets or newsletter unless today's witnesses overrun (no one wants that – the parties' counsel have to write their closings tomorrow)…

… or of course unless there is a significant development outside of court. Then I'll be back on Friday to cover the closing oral submissions and hopefully get copies of the written closings.

We are still on a break, here are some arrivals from this morning. Sara Morrisons' solicitor Mark Chambers

Two members of the BFF's legal team, including solicitor Gráinne Rice

Sara Morrison's counsel – Naomi Cunningham and her junior Dr Charlotte Elves

And Sara Morrison (l) arriving with another member of her legal team this morning.

Actually I'm going to start a new thread. Come find me.

🧵Ends


Session 2:

40 tweets

Welcome to Day 8 Session 2 of Morrison v Belfast Film Festival employment tribunal. Lisa Barros D'Sa – co-chair of the BFF has been giving evidence all morning. We are at Killymeal House.

Here is this morning's thread of live tweets.

x.com/nickwallis/status/1991084001730170897?s=20

[Session has just restarted with a very serious warning from the judge about people taking photos in court. What is the world coming to etc etc]

[For abbreviations see previous tweet thread]

And please note everything I tweet is a summary and characterisation of what is said and happening in court. Nothing is a direct quote unless it is in "direct quotes".

NC has taken LB to an email from 4 July in which MD says: "I will send all the info to HR company now" – which suggests the decision has been taken to start investigation (iv)
LB agrees – not sure of the date it was decided tho

NC are you saying you weren't a party to the decision to instruct Think People
LB we discussed it but the decision would not have been mine.
NC whose?
LB "that would have been Michele's, we would have been there to advise"

[NC takes her to a text from MC saying "As a board member I think Sara should be removed
from any of our trans and queer projects at once."
Board member Laurence McKeown (LM) weighs in: "I totally agree. As you say Mark, it doesn't affect her
employment rights but it removes her, and the
festival, from the issue. People would be totally
justified in refusing to work With her but we shouldn't
put them in that position. I looked at her comments
on YouTube. – appalling."
Lucy Baxter (LB) another board member says: "Yes I think this is the right way forward. It was a
mistake to include Sara in the plans but this can
easily be remedied now."
NC if that was Lucy's view it really was a mistake for MD to put SM's name in that 3 July email. It was a mistake.
LB I don't nec think so given her job, Lucy is saying it was a mistake, but that was her opinion in that moment.

NC SM was anxious about it and didn't want it to happen
SD she said in evidence she was happy about it
J that's my recollection
NC it's perfectly possible to agree to something whilst being anxious about it if your boss wants you to do it
SD SM said in xe the email was sent with her agreement and it was an act of support, this is a fundamentally different case

… and that's not permissible
J NC?
NC okay let's put it this way – was MD reporting honestly about the way this email came about
LB no reason to believe not

[NC takes her to SM's WS: "I expressed my
discomfort with having my name on that email, noting that we are experts in curating festivals
and can offer a broad perspective on what should be featured… Despite my hesitation,
Michele sent the email to the groups using the contacts from my Inclusion Excel spreadsheet,
cc-ing me in after I had left for the day"]

NC "people are often quite suggestible" when in a power imbalance combined with stress, aren't they?
LB "they may be but I can't comment about it in relation to this"
NC it was put to C in xe and she agreed that she wasn't comfortable to send the email
LB and that's why they decided MD should sent the email and the disco was about what was SM's job
NC and if MD couldn't see the "unwisdom" of putting her name at the top of the cc list, SM's concern should have alerted
LB "i think she was maanging the situation as best as she oculd in the moment"
NC it was described as a "mistake" to send that email – truth was, it wasn't a mistake at all this was the implementation of the plan to "accelerate matters" which in obedience to MC, you and MD made on 28 June
LB "no it wasn't and no such plan was made."

[We got to another part of the bundle – the email from Amie Martin re Caleb J Roberts.]

[there has been a discussion in court – we are not going to refer to the person above by name going forward]

[though there is no reporting restriction or anonymity order. so I will report what's being said in court, but reporters, are atmo able to use their name. SD agrees "the horse has bolted" on that]

NC if the complaint in that email is true it's v serious
LB yes it's v serious
NC we're in gross misconduct (GM) territory
LB can't say
NC you would have a grasp of what constitutes GM
LB it's certainly v serious
NC yet it wasn't followed up with a disc iv
LB we were already…

… investigating.
NC but this came in on 7 July and I would suggest it needed an urgent iv if anyone thought it might be true
LB there was an iv
NC that gives the game away doesn't it – you were already on track to get SM out – you didn't need an iv on an allegation which

… looked on the face of it, untrue.
LB no this would need to be scrutinised before any disc action
[let me see if I can copy and paste the complaint again: "Hi Michele,
I hope that you are keeping well.
My name is [xxxxxx] and my short film Homebird was screened at the 2022 edition of the
Belfast Film Festival. I was also a key crew member on the feature film Ballywalter directed and
written by my good friends Prasanna Puwanarajah and Stacey Gregg.
I want to preface this letter with the fact that I am an openly transgender man, but my work does
not focus on this topic. Nor did the films I was representing at the festival have anything to do with
me beings trans. I also want to preface that until this interaction, I had never met Sara Morrison.
I drafted an email to you in November after having an incident with Sara Morrison during the
festival, and again on the 16th of April after Sara publically spoke at an anti-transgender rally in
Belfast city centre that was circulated online. On both occasions I opted not to send the emails,
feeling powerless and quite worried about the possibility of being exiled from the Belfast Film
Festival for speaking about my experience.
At the Belfast Film Festival in November 2022 – during the after-screening drinks of Ballywalter in
the Cineworld foyer, I was approached by Sara Morrison. I had never met Sara before, and had to
google her after the interaction, shocked that she was listed as the Audience Development and
Inclusion Officer.
Sara initiated a conversation with me by name, knowing who I was. This conversation quickly
became incredibly uncomfortable, turning into what felt like borderline targeted harassment. She
insisted on making it known to me that she was a TERF, standing for 'Trans Exclusionary Radical
Feminist' — repeating this to me multiple times, adding that I "probably hated her, hated her guts,
thought she was a cunt" etc. despite having never met her before. It clicked with me then, that it
was because I was transgenderthat she was telling me this -creating an intentionally antagonistic
conversation.
Several negative comments were made in relation to me being trans and that despite this (me
being transgender) she still enjoyed my short film Homebird and thought that young gay people
should see it. She also alluded to the fact that she had my film removed from competition by alerting
the programmers to a private screening that Homebird had for cast and crew in the QFT a year prior,
with our co-founder Outburst Arts – but I don't know if she had the power to do this or if she was
just saying this to be oddly antagonistic.
I was genuinely quite shocked that someone would approach a stranger and to their face tell them
that they didn't like trans people, and I awkwardly removed myself from the conversation with the
help of my partner and my producer, who witnessed the whole thing – equally angry and completely
baffled at what had just happened. This left me very upset and quite powerless on what should have
been a night of celebrating Ballywalter, causing me to have to excuse myself for a while before rejoining.
When my own short film was screened on the 6th of November, I had to be convinced to
attend by my partner and producer who had my back, because I was scared to be approached again
— feeling like I wasn't welcome or didn't belong at the festival.
I truly think that given the very open and vocal viewpoints that Sara holds about transgender people
(both in person and online) coupled with my experience and potentially the experiences of others — I
don't feel she is fit for the position she holds. I would hope that the Belfast Film Festival be a place to
encourage minority communities across Northern Ireland to contribute, but with an Inclusion Officer
that is loudly anti-trans, I don't feel safe sharing my work or celebrating film at my local festival
anymore. I am really saddened that Sara is someone whose purpose is to create equal opportunity
and engagement for audiences regardless of who they are, but holds contempt for people like me. I
absolutely love the Belfast Film Festival and have been honoured for my work to take part, but I feel
unwelcome.
Thank you for your time as this is quite a lengthy letter, but I hope it can be of use to hear from a
trans person that was directly affected by Sara's behaviour as an audience member, filmmaker, and
lover of film in Belfast.
All the very best,
[xxxxx] (He/Him).]

[We move on to LB's bossing of the iv into SM and the email which explains what the iv is all about]
NC no mention here of the email above
LB the terms do mention other matters which may come to light
NC but this had already come to light

NC your letter talks about the LWS event, but doesn't mention the email complaint of 7 July. Can you help the tribunal to understand why you had this really serious complaint from a seemingly vulnerable behaviour who complained about seriously bad behaviour towards them by SM…

… and yet it's not mentioned in the terms of the iv
LB Bethany put this together and the terms and the section there is the oppo to put matters which may come to our attn – "that's all I can say"
NC in hindsight isn't it incomprehensible that wasn't put "onto the charge sheet" for iv on 25 July

LB I wouldn't call it a charge sheet
NC matters to be investigated – let's not get hung up on that
LB it does seem incomprehensible – Bethany put it together and it wasn't included
NC put it to you it's not incomp – it happened for 2 reasons – the iv you wanted was already…

… in train on grounds of transphobia and the complaint didn't look viable
LB I don't accept either of those points
NC that ind. was employed by Outburst Arts who you'd already had 2 complaints from since 4 July and Amie Martin who forwarded it to you, had worked for BFF
LB I have no idea
NC "if that's true, it's all looking pretty incestuous isn't it"
LB "no I wouldn't describe it as that"

NC takes LB to a text message she sends to MC and LM (among others): "Hi all, MT and Michele are on holiday this week so I wanted to give you a quick update. Michele has gathered further formal complaints relating to Sara. And refusal to do certain aspects of her job involving these issues and groups in itself constitutes gross misconduct. So pending further legal discussion
things are moving toward a clear destination – again
it's just about doing everything in the correct way."

NC that language is a giveaway "clear destination" – you've already decided.
LB disagrees
NC takes her to her WS "It is correct
that pending further legal discussions, things were moving toward a clear destination-
the clear destination being the fact-finding investigation."

NC an investigation is not a destination, is it?
LB suggests it is
NC that is a deliberate attempt to mislead the tribunal isn't
LB not at all
NC and a "fairly desperate" attempt to rewrite the meaning of what you put "candidly" in your chat
LB not at all

NC you're unmistakably talking in terms of dismissal at this point
LB no I'm saying it's very serious and things need to be investigated by impartial bodies
NC and clear destination for GM is dismissal isn't it
LB no the destination i'm talking about is the investigation

[NC takes LB to her iv into SM: "My name is Lisa and I have been appointed alongside Keara Paterson, Senior HR Consultant at Think
People Consulting to conduct a formal grievance investigation into complaints raised by Sara
O'Gorman in accordance with the Company's grievance Procedure.
Keara will take notes of the meeting and also provide any HR Support and Guidance, and you will be
given the opportunity to review the notes and to make any necessary amendments at the conclusion
of this meeting. These will be summary notes and not verbatim."]

NC it's your iv here. you're in charge
LB no I don't think so – Keara was providing knowledge about HR matters and expertise
NC why did you take charge of the iv
LB a senior person needed to look at it and we concluded it needed to be me as I was avail
NC other people…

… could have done it, couldn't they? you were busy coming back from London
NC you were the wrong person to appoint as the investigator of SM's grievance claim given you were involved in setting up the iv which SM claimed a grievance about
LB no impartiality was a consideration which
NC you could hardly have been closer to the subject matter and the grievance given you were involved in the drafting of the investigation letter and approved it
LB yes
NC the nec impartiality could be brought by Keara Paterson (KP) – she could overrule you
LB I think she would
NC so do you agree if you looked into the grievance by yourself it would have been unfair
LB it would have been unfair because I'm not really qualified to conduct a grievance – I don't have the knowledge KP has
[NC takes her to the grievance outcome which is signed only by KP and written in the first person throughout]
NC so the documentary record is that this was KP's iv
LB "that was the correct way to express this outcome"
NC if all you wanted was impartiality – why involved a board member at all
LB "as an internal mechanism I understood that that was the necessary thing to do for me to be there to oversee it"
NC "the truth is you were determined to oversee it because you were determined to have control of the outcome of the G process weren't you"
LB no
NC and having KP sign the letter was a belated attempt to distance you from the process because it was patently unfair.
LB no
NC no further questions
[SD picks up for BFF]
SD it was put to you there were no complaints from women's sector
LB yes
SD as part of the grievance procedure did you consider social media
LB yes
[SD goes to the bundle and asks LB to read tweet "Having their 'inclusion' staff member Sarah Morrison
saying the women’s sector is a racket and trying to prevent trans women and men
being offered equality and help is the opposite of inclusive…”]

SD you were asked if you knew the allegation against SM by xxxx amounted to GM did you
LB no I am not an expert

SD you were taken to an email and it was suggested it was "somewhat over-heated" and you said there were other incidents you were aware of – were you aware at

… the time you saw the email what the other incidents were
LB outside of the rally… [didn't catch it sorry]

SD no further q's judge
J thank you LB that's the end of your xe and re-ex so you can go back.
SD I think Moyra Lock is very short witness we could maybe fit them in
NC ML will be very short indeed. Both witnesses will be short – can we carry on with both
SD I agree…

… but I can't see Mr McKeown atmo
J asks someone to find Laurence McKeown – MD leaves to get him.
SD calls Moyra Lock (ML)
[she is affirmed]

SD takes her through her WS and she confirms it is hers, her signature a "true and accurate account of your evidence"
ML yes
Dr Charlotte Elves (CE) is xe-ing ML
CE can we go to par 1 of your WS – says you have responsibility for pay
ML yes
CE including administering sick pay

ML yes
CE and you say you were instructed verbally by MD to put SM on Stat Sick Pay (SSP)
ML yes
CE when did you receive that instruction
ML "I don't recall that exact date but it's going to be before the 25 July"
CE so you received the instruction before she went sick

ML wouldn't be until we got the sick note – sick note would have been received and I would have been instructed to put SM on SSP
[CE goes to the bundle]

CE seems like you got the sick note on 3 Aug
ML yes
CE quite apparent you'd never put anyone on SSP before
ML correct
CE so from when you started in 2022 and you taking advice from Bethany O'Neill re SM you would not have put someone on SSP
ML there are v few employees…

… I don't recall anyone being off sick and sending in a sick note in my time there
J how many employees did you administer
ML three
CE no further qs
SD no re-ex
[evidence ends. lunch]

Okay I'm going to start a new thread for the final witness, Laurence McKeown.

N


Session 3:

33 tweets

Welcome to Day 8 Session 3 of Morrison v Belfast Film Festival (BFF) – this should be the last witness evidence session of the tribunal. Laurence McKeown has just arrived to give evidence beginning at 1.30pm

The previous witness, Moyra Lock, has left the building.

And here is the thread of live tweets from Session 2 of today which featured Lock's evidence and the second part of Lisa Barros D'Sa's evidence.

x.com/nickwallis/status/1991112446560367084?s=20

In an internal msg to BFF colleagues he said of Sara Morrison (who is bringing a claim against the BFF) : "People would be totally justified in refusing to work with her but we shouldn't put them in that position. I looked at her comments on YouTube. – appalling."

This is the transcript of what SM said at the Let Women Speak event on 16 April 2023 in Belfast:

"Thank you everyone, every single woman, every single man that has turned up today. I know so
many people who have not been able to turn up today because they are frightened.
Today, however, the women of Belfast have gathered here and they are saying no. We do not
consent.
I am going to tell you a quote: every great cause begins as a movement, begins as a business and
eventually degenerates into a racket. Do you need me to repeat it? Every great cause begins as a
movement, becomes a business and eventually degenerates into a racket.
So apparently there is no place for hate. Let me tell you a story. The same tactics that are being used
by the anti-abortion campaign across Ireland are being used now by Alliance For Choice. Then it was
a deliberate campaign of harassment and intimidation against women. This resulted in women being
shamed and silenced and this is currently being repeated by those in [inaudible] and those over right
over there.
Alliance For Choice wanted women to speak up about their private experiences. These are same
women they wish to silence.
Do you think this is fair?
This organisation has had tens and hundreds of thousands of pounds generated through funding,
donations, charitable donations, taxes who knows? How does this make you feel? Do they serve you
as a taxpayer?
Again, every great cause begins as a movement, becomes a business and eventually degenerates into
a racket. Do these so-called women's organisations speak for you? Do these self-styled messiahs
represent us? These organisations are paid thousands of pounds through the public purse to sing
songs to silence women speaking. Is that where you want your money going? These organisations,
these women's organisations Wk DA, Alliance For Choice, Women's Policy Group Northern Ireland,
The Women's Sector Lobbyist, Rape Crisis Nl.
I started this new iteration of Rape Crisis Nl, this is not the rape crisis I wanted. We need to keep men
out of women's spaces.
They have morphed into a deliberate campaign of bullying and intimidation into silence through
harassment and bullying the very women they should be protecting and [inaudible].
These organisations do not represent me.
Your vote counts on the 18th of May. I see we have some elective representatives up on the bridge.
You might want to take note of them and not vote for them.
They are here to silence women.
Ask your local representative what they are doing to support women. Not through these
organisations, ask them how the women and children of Belfast and across Northern Ireland are safe
on the streets and in their homes and how their safety and dignity is being protected.
We pay their taxes.These so-called women's organisations are getting so much money. How much money will it take to
silence women? How much money will you approve?
They say they represent women but women with different and equally legitimate views. Women who
do not believe the sacred tenants that sex work is work and surrogacy does not exploit women.
These are the women who they silence. Those women they turn their backs on.
Every great cause begins as a movement, becomes a business and eventually degenerates into a
racket."

A REMINDER THAT EVERYTHING I TWEET WHEN COURT IS SITTING IS A SUMMARY OR CHARACTERISATION OF WHAT IS BEING SAID OR IS HAPPENING IN COURT. NOTHING IS VERBATIM UNLESS IT IS IN "DIRECT QUOTES"

If you want to get tonight's newsletter or just want to buy me a coffee (or a pint, given we have a day off tomorrow), please consider making a small one-off donation:
genderblog.net/donate/

I would be the most grateful etc etc

okay here we go – court is sitting
SM Sara Morrison – claimant – C
LM Dr Laurence McKeown BFF
SD Sean Doherty – BFF barrister
NC Naomi Cunningham – SM barrister
J judge

LM has been sworn in and is now confirm his witness statement (WS) is "true and accurate account of his evidence"

[CE Charlotte Elves is xe-ing LM for SM, she is NC's junior]
CE takes him to his WS par 5: "The Claimant has raised the issue of Michele Devlin publicly endorsing Sinn Fein’s
Deirdre Hargey in an election as somehow equivalent to her speaking at a public rally
in Belfast. I see no similarity whatsoever. Apart from being the founder of the
Respondent organisation and being a Board Member ever since, I am publicly known
for my life as a former IRA volunteer, a political prisoner who took part in the 1981
hunger strike, and a supporter of Sinn Fein and the Republican Movement. I have
written about my life in various books and publications and made a film about my prison
experiences. It is all very public. However, none of that in any way ever conflicted with
my role as a member of the board of management of the Respondent, as I was always
very clear about the separation between board membership and my life and work as a
private citizen. There never was any challenge to that from any member of the public.
In the same way, there was never any challenge from the public to the Respondent
when Michele Devlin endorsed Deirdre Hargey."

CE you recognise a possible conflict between your views and those of SM
LM no my work has been about working with people who were once sworn enemies – I speak at IRA commemorations
CE you accept a separation between personal opinions and your role on the board is v important
LM yes

CE takes LM to the transcript of SM's speech at LWS
CE she didn't mention her employer in that speech
LM no
CE doesn't mention her industry
LM no
CE attended rally in her own time
LM yep

CE so there's nothing to id her to BFF
LM "belfast is a small city, the arts sector is a small sector, so Sara would immediately be identified"

CE so other than being recgnisable there's nothing she did
LM "I don't agree. she appeared at a public rally with two people who have very contentious views and
it would be like me appearing on a platform with dissident republicans who still advocate for armed struggle" – if that happened I would not be on the board of the BFF
CE that's what you want the tribunal to draw as a comparison – SM's actions with dissident republicans
LM no it's about what you can and can't do as an employee as an includsion and diversity officer and "criticsing women's groups and appearing with poeple whose opinions here have caused a lot of difficulties"

[raises MD's appearance in an election video for Sinn Fein with permission the BFF's board]
CE the CEO of BFF could reasonably be expected alienate unionists
LM I don't think so
CE she was given permission because MD had the right sort of opinions for the BFF
LM no if SM wanted to endorse the greens or unions she could – people disagree and work together "it's what it's like here"
CE let me give you a hypothetical – say SM wanted to appear at a rally for Amnesty International – it campaigns on human rights abuses and reproductive rights – if SM did that and she criticised human rights situation
"any complaint that the board would get would be investigated"
CE that's just not credible
LM you're calling into question the credibility of the board… if the board gets a complaint it will investigated
CE whether it's credible or incredible
LM the board would have to see whether it warrants pursuing and how to pursue it
CE what shocked you about SMs speech was her vilification of the women's sector
LM yes
CE and you say something similar later on about her criticsm of the women's sector –
LM I said she was entitled to her views
CE you don't mention transgender people, trans rights or gender identity or sex realist beliefs of the LGBT community at all
LM no
CE so you're giving the impression the problem that you have is ONLY about what SM said about women's sector
LM "yes and being on the platform in the first place"

[CE takes LM to 4 May board meeting minutes]
CE would you agree the issue mentioned here is about the LGBTQ community and not women's groups
LM as a board member [missed this sorry]
CE asks the q again – the note as we read it now is about the LGBT community
SD I have…

… difficulty with this q – it's not an accurate interpretation of that note
J ?
CE the only crit in this note of women's centres is by SM
LM Belfast is a small city, the women's sector is small the LGBT is small – it's very close. I think some of the comments i had read of SM was more about women's centres in general but it's broader than that.

[NC takes him to an MD WhatsApp (WA) exchange on 5 July 2023 LM writes "What is Sara's response to all of this?
It IS quite stark that her official position is 'Equality
and Inclusion Officer' and yet she appears on a
platform With Jolene Bunting whose outrageous
views across and against a very broad spectrum are
very well known, and Posie Parker's campaign
against trans is equally well known. Does the festival
have to take more action than simply release a
statement?"]
CE do you agree you are highlighting there the problem is her appearance at this rally
LM given her role and the people who were there, this causes issues for the festival

CE and below it you say "And were others "letting women speak" speaking in
support of trans?" – so your focus was on trans in this
LM it all became "intermingled"
J wants clarity on timeline of WA messages

CE I think this is a WA chat between you and MD
LM agrees
CE so the issue raised at 21:54 is one concerning what SM may or may not have said about trans people rather than womens
LM my intention is to get advice on what they are saying as a citizen or as an employee

J what's your q
CE the focus here is on what SM was thought to have said about trans rather than women's groups
[LM points to MD's comment – "She maintains she is not trans phobic. Her comments at the rally were about freedom of speech and "letting women speak" and his response..

"And were others "letting women speak" speaking in
support of trans?" – says they were getting a lot of attention in the media and emails about it and he wanted clarity on what happened]

CE takes her to another LM message "Yes Lisa, as Michele said, treading a thin line. I think the
suggestion of removing her from any engagement with
trans or aueer arouos seems to be the solution."

[him, sorry]
CE if the problem was women's groups, removing her from engagement with trans or queer groups would not be the solution, would it
[LM speaks quickly and I'm not picking him up v well]
[replies saying its about the broader piece, her job etc]

CE takes LM to MC's text "As a board member 1. think Sara Should be. removed
from any of our trans and queer projects at once."
CE this is about trans, not women's groups again
LM SM's decision to speak at LWS was causing problems. we agree she said nothing transphobic. it was best to withdraw her until we knew what the situation was.

CE you reply to MC "I totally agree. As you say Mark, it doesn't affect her
employment rights but it removes her, and the
festival, from the issue. "
CE the issue is trans
LM it's the wider context
CE your WS says the problem with SM was about her crit of women's groups

LM no it wasn't misleading at all
CE omitting to mention all of these discussions about trans issues that are an issue of concern
LM no there's nothing misleading in my WS at all it's a very clear exposition
CE if you had connected her criticisms with of trans you know…

… you'd be encroaching on her protected belief
LM I've heard a lot of theories in this tribunal. This was a staffing issues
CE if you had…
LM I'm not going down this road
CE I can ask the q and you can refuse to answer it – if you had linked your concerns with SM and its effects on the trans community that would have been a reaction to SM's protected sex realist beliefs
LM we weren't dealing with hypotheticals, we were dealing with the situation as it had arisen
CE no further q's
SD no re-examination
J so that concludes all the evidence?
SD it does indeed
[written submissions in by 9am Friday, oral submissions on each others statements and overarching comments and answers to panel q's at 11.30am Friday]

[hearing ends]

Okay that's it then – back on Friday – thanks very much for reading this far and all the comments, retweets etc. One more plug for the incoming newsletter – a one-off donation gets you signed up . Thanks to everyone who has made this viable.

genderblog.net/donate/


Live Tweet Archives

  • ▼2026
  • ►2025