-
Peggie loses RCN tribunal
Read More…: Peggie loses RCN tribunal“This judgment makes worrying reading for all trade union members” – Sandie Peggie spokesperson. Sandie Peggie has lost her employment tribunal against her union, the Royal College of Nursing. The judgment, handed down today, dismisses Peggie’s claims that she was discriminated against on the grounds of her gender critical beliefs. Peggie had three complaints. Firstly, that her union rep should have recognised that she was manifesting her protected beliefs (and should have acted appropriately) when she described being suspended for voicing her objections to a male doctor changing in the female changing rooms where she worked. Secondly, that the RCN…
-
Welsh Gender Safeguarding Fail Laid Bare
Read More…: Welsh Gender Safeguarding Fail Laid Bare“Two seconds” to diagnosis… New papers released by NHS Wales and the breadcrumb trail they create has given us more information on why all surgery referrals by the Welsh Gender Service (WGS) have been halted. The decision to suspend all gender surgeries was taken in August by the NHS Wales Joint Commissioning Committee (NWJCC). The main driver was evidence – first set out on this website – that the WGS was referring patients for surgery at a far higher rate than its equivalents in any other UK nation. We now have more information on the additional concerns which led to…
-
Did NHS Chief Medical Officer suppress puberty blocker information?
Read More…: Did NHS Chief Medical Officer suppress puberty blocker information?“Keep this audit to ourselves for the time being” The former Chief Medical Officer of NHS Sussex asked a colleague who had prepared a report on the number of children being prescribed puberty blockers by local doctors to “keep this audit to ourselves for the time being”. On 7 May 2021 Dr Elizabeth Gill was emailed the result of an audit collated by Dr Stephen Pike, the Clinical Programme Lead in Medicines Management and Deputy Medical Director Sussex Clinical Commissioning Groups within NHS Sussex. The audit indicated there were eight under 16s receiving puberty blockers prescribed by doctors within NHS…
-
NHS exec skewers own legal case
Read More…: NHS exec skewers own legal caseAdam Doyle gives evidence in Redvers v NHS Sussex An NHS exec accepted in court today that a key element of his defence against a gender critical doctor’s discrimination claim was “absurd”. He also accepted he was aware of concerns that a transgender GP, Dr Sam Hall, was prescribing hormones to children in contravention of the policies put in place by the organisation he ran. Adam Doyle, the former CEO of NHS Sussex is the Second Respondent in an employment tribunal brought by a safeguarding specialist and GP, Dr Sarah Redvers. The First Respondent is NHS Sussex itself. Redvers claims…
-
NHS knew of concerns about trans Dr in 2020
Read More…: NHS knew of concerns about trans Dr in 2020Whistleblower told NHS Sussex and NHS England of problems with Dr Sam Hall’s methods and was accused of transphobia. An NHS Doctor raised the alarm about the activities of Dr Sam Hall in 2020, a full five years before NHS Sussex started an investigation into Brighton’s WellBN clinic – which concluded it had it caused “actual potential harm” to its young patients and “fell substantially below” the professional standards of care required. Dr Sarah Redvers claims that as a result of her whistleblowing in 2020, she was victimised, accused of transphobia and put under investigation. Redvers is currently taking NHS…
-
Peggie v RCN Day 7: Closing Submissions
Read More…: Peggie v RCN Day 7: Closing SubmissionsToday was the final day of the Peggie v RCN employmeny tribunal in which Nurse Sandie Peggie is making three claims against her union, the Royal College of Nursing. Peggie believes: Peggie says the reason for the above is because of her gender critical views. Therefore her union – which she submits is in the grip of gender ideology – discriminated against her. After six days of witness evidence, the legal representatives for both parties were given the opportunity to make closing submissions to the judge. Naomi Cunningham, Sandie Peggie’s barrister spoke first. After lunch David Hay KC, the RCN’s…
-
Peggie v RCN Day 6: Patricia Marquis
Read More…: Peggie v RCN Day 6: Patricia MarquisPatricia Marquis, the Executive Director of the Royal College of Nursing in England is obviously an intelligent, personable and compassionate individual with the requisite element of corporate steel required to reach the higher echelons of large organisation. At times today she was at a loss to answer some of the questions being put to her by Sandie Peggie’s barrister, Naomi Cunningham. Not because the questions were particularly complicated, but when combined with the evidence, Marquis was forced to confront a period of time when a lot of people in civil society – particularly those in the public sector – lost…
-
Peggie v RCN Day 5: Gillian Tait
Read More…: Peggie v RCN Day 5: Gillian TaitMost of today was taken up with the evidence of RCN Senior Officer Gillian Tait, but the first hour and forty minutes was dedicated to finishing the cross-examination of Union Officer Stuart Fraser – Tait’s direct report. Naomi Cunningham, Sandie Peggie’s barrister, had two main strands to her questioning of Fraser. The first was about a trans-identifying male called Freda Wallace “(She/Ra)” who in December last year posted four photos on BlueSky with the caption: “Royal College of Nursing- Education on discrimination. I used Dr Upton’s case to explain how gender critical organisations target NHS trusts. It was amazing to…
-
Peggie v RCN Day 4 Pt 2: Stuart Fraser
Read More…: Peggie v RCN Day 4 Pt 2: Stuart FraserThis is part two of my report into Day 4 of Nurse Sandie Peggie’s employment tribunal claim against the Royal College of Nursing. You can read Part 1 “Nurses Assemble”, here. As with Friday’s cross-examination of Norman Provan, the interest is not in what the RCN man said in evidence, but the chain of logic that Sandie Peggie’s barrister Naomi Cunningham presented to Fraser, highlighting inconsistencies (and flat out misstatements of the law) in the RCN’s approach to gender issues. Stuart Fraser has been an RCN Officer for five years. He was the first representative Sandie Peggie spoke to on…
-
Peggie v RCN Day 4 Pt 1: Nurses Assemble
Read More…: Peggie v RCN Day 4 Pt 1: Nurses AssembleThis is part one of my report into Day 4 of Nurse Sandie Peggie’s employment tribunal claim against the Royal College of Nursing. You can read part two “Peggie v RCN Day 4 Pt 2: Stuart Fraser” here. The featured evidence in the report below came from two nurses in England who got into difficulties within their NHS Trusts for the crimes of misgendering (Jennifer Melle in Surrey) or complaining about a man in their changing rooms (Bethany Hutchison and her six fellow nurses in Darlington). Proceedings began with Jennifer Melle setting out her evidence in chief to Sandie Peggie’s…











